All Starr Caribbean Cafe Menu (Updated 2026)

Welcome to All Starr Caribbean Cafe, a gem nestled in Trenton, NJ, where the flavors of the Caribbean come alive. This beloved eatery, located at 308 Maple Ave, specializes in heartfelt dishes that transport you to the islands. Guests rave about their mouthwatering oxtails, renowned for their tenderness and rich gravy, along with hearty sides like beans and rice, cabbage, and macaroni cheese that keep patrons returning for more.

Among the highlights is also the iconic beef patty, acclaimed as the best in the area, offering an authentic taste reminiscent of Jamaica. While the flavors are undeniable, some diners echo a sentiment about service speed—be prepared for a leisurely wait, but rest assured, your meal will be well worth it. Embrace the warmth of island cuisine at All Starr Caribbean Cafe, where deliciousness meets a laid-back ambiance.

The menu predominantly features traditional Caribbean dishes centered around hearty proteins such as oxtail and jerk chicken, paired with staple sides like peas and rice, cabbage, and plantains. Pricing ranges from $10 to $20, indicating a mid-level affordability with most items positioned as budget-friendly meal options. Premium items likely include specialty preparations like oxtail, which typically involve longer cooking times and richer ingredients. The menu composition suggests suitability for lunch and dinner, with no specific breakfast offerings evident. Overall, the selection supports quick comparison for diners seeking authentic Caribbean flavors within a moderate price range.